Those who disbelieve and die and
remain kaafir, those are the one upon whom is the curse of Allah and Angels
and all Humans.
AlFatwa International No.
by Dr. Syed
had renewed its challenge of Mubahila in Sept 1998
to the leader of Ahmadiyya Jamaat. It has been more than three months and
Mirza Tahir Ahmad Qadiani, the leader of Ahmadiyya Movement has yet to
acknowledge and accept this challenge. This challenge is being reproduced
here. Just as I, Dr. Syed Rashid Ali, have come out challenging Mirza Tahir
for the prayer duel to protect the honour of Holy Prophet of Islam SAAW,
I request Qadianis/Ahmadis to force their leader that if he really believe
in the claims of prophethood/messiahship/mahdihood by Mirza Ghulam Ahmad
Qadiani, then he should come out to protect the honour of his prophet.
The present challenge
of Mubahila has been based on the following Hadith of Rasoolullah SAAW:
"If following four
(habits) are found in a person, then he is a PERFECT HYPOCRITE.
And if one sign
is found in a person, then he has one sign of hypocricy until he leaves
Readers will note that
the Holy Prophet SAAW has clearly indicated how to identify a PERFECT HYPOCRITE
and obviously such qualities do not befit a good muslim, let alone a prophet.
Let us now see in which category of Hypocrisy does Mirza Ghulam A Qadiani,
the founder of Ahmadiyya Movement fits. You must remember that Mirza Ghulam
claimed that he was a prophet, a messenger, Promised Messiah, Imam Mahdi
etc. In the presence of such claims, to what extent he is permitted to
lie or embezzle or flout his promises or use abusive language for his opponents,
that I leave for the readers to decide.
When he is entrusted
(with something), he embezzles;
When he talks, he lies;
When he promises, he
flouts it; &
When he quarrels, he
(Bukhari & Muslim)
remind readers that ALL PROPHETS of Allah had examplery character and mannerism.
They had NEVER lied, NEVER embezzled, NEVER broken a promise and NEVER
used abusive language for their opponents.
Readers are also
reminded of the grandiose nature of the claims of Mirza Saheb whereby he
had the audacity to claim to be the replica of Jesus Christ, Zil and Burooz
of Holy Prophet Muhammad SAAW, claims of excellent conduct which is the
unique honour bestowed upon by Allah on Holy Prophet SAAW. Some of the
examples of such claims are as follows.
CLAIMS by Mirza of EQUALITY/SUPERIORITY OVER HOLY PROPHETS, Syedna MUHAMMAD
& JESUS (SAAW)
"When I am the Holy
Prophet re-incarnate and when all the accomplishments of Muhammad including
the prophethood are reflected in my mirror of my shadiness, then who is
the man who has claimed prophethood in a seperate being ?" (Ek Ghalti
Ka Izala, p.8; Roohani Khazain, vol.18,p.212)
"The truth is that the
spirituality of the (reincarnated) Holy Prophet at the end of the 6th millennium
(i.e. these days in the form of Mirza), is much more stronger, more complete
and forceful than in those early years, rather it is like the 14th (moonlit)
night". (Khutbah-e-Ilhamiyah, Roohani Khazain, vol.16, pp. 271-272)
wal lazeena m'ahoo, ashiddao 'ala alkuffare rohamao bainahum' in this revelation
God has named me Mohammed and Messenger as well."
(Roohani Khazain vol 18 p.207)
"I have claimed to be
Maseel Maseeh, which stupid people thinks that it is Promised Messiah .....
I have never claimed to be the Messiah ibne Maryam. Anyone who accuses
me of it, he is absolutely a liar and fabricator. I have been constantly
announcing for the last eight years that i am Maseel Maseeh, that is, Hazrat
Eisa AS's certain spiritual properties and nature and habits and virtues
has been given to me as well by God AlMighty." (Izala-e-Auham, Roohani
Khazain vol 3 p.192)
"I proclaim that I am
the Promised Messiah about whom every God's book has prophecised that he
will appear in the Last Days." (Tohfa-e-Golravia, Roohani Khazain
vol 17 p.295)
"It has been revealed
to me that this humble self in my Poverty and Humility and Reliance on
God and Sacrifice and According to Signs and Radiances, is an copy of the
first life of Maseeh; and this humble self's nature and the nature of Maseeh
resembles each other so much as if two pieces of the same atom or two seeds
of the same tree."
(Braheen-e-Ahmadiyya Part 3, Roohani Khazain vol 1 p. 593)
God is the one who has
sent his mesenger, this humble self, with good conduct and manners.” (Roohani
Khazain Vol 17 P. 426 by Mirza Qadiani)
In the following
passages, I will endeavour to show you the two faces of Mirza Ghulam -
his claims of examplery character on the one hand and the proofs of his
PERFECT HYPOCRICY on the other. Lets
us analyse various aspects of the life of Mirza Ghulam in the light of
Hadith of Rasoolullah SAAW.
Lies of Mirza Ghulam A Qadiani
Mahdi is not anyone’s
student. I swear that this is exactly my condition Nobody can prove that
any human has taught me Quran …….” (Roohani Khazain Vol 14
p. 394 by Mirza Qadiani)
At 10 years of age an
Arabic Teacher was appointed for me whose name was Fazal Ahmed ….and when
I was 17 -18 years of age I was educated by another Molvi Saheb whose nem
was Gul Ali Shah, who was appointed by my father in Qadian to teach
me.” (Roohani Khazain Vol 13. P. 180)
Embezzlement of Money & The Broken Promises
When I was 6-7 years
old a person teacher was employed for me who taught me Holy Quran….. and
his name was Fazal Ilahi.” (Roohani Khazain Vol 13. P. 180)
A Qadiani announced in 1879 that God has appointed him to prove the truthfulness
of Islam. For this purpose he advertised that he is going to write a book,
Braheen-e-Ahmadiyya, in 50 volumes. But since he was a poor man, he appealed
for money! He advertised for Muslims to come forward and purchase the book
in advance. He promised to send them the volumes as soon as they are printed.
(Majmooa-e-Ishtehaarat, Collection of Advertisements, vol.1 p.18-19)
contributed and purchased the book in advance as is mentioned in the initial
volumes of Braheen-e-Ahmadiyya. However after publishing 4 volumes in the
next 4 years, the reality dawned on him. Now for the rest of his life probably
he would be writing, publishing and distributing Braheen-e-Ahmadiyya -
a book for which he has already recieved advance payments. In other words
no further hope of monetary gain. He stopped writing the book. Despite
protests from buyers who had made advance payments or had made generous
contributions for this book. He said:
Ghulam's Abusive Language for his Opponents
“Now God is the real
and apparent incharge and caretaker of this book and I have no idea how
many volumes of it (Braheen-e-Ahmadiyya ) He is going to publish it.” (
Roohani Khazain Vol 1 P. 47)
Years after years
Mirza Ghulam A. Qadiani, the so-called "PROPHET, PROMISED MESSIAH, MAHDI"
kept flouting his promise. For the next 23 years he wrote, published and
sold some 80 other books. Fifth volume of Braheen-e-Ahmadiyya was not published
until after 23 years. However if someone expected Mirza Ghulam to be remorseful
about breaking his promises and embezzling the funds given to him, then
he can just forget it. On the contrary he wrote in the preface of this
"At first I had
intended to write 50 parts, but I contended with writing 5 and since the
Khazain Vol 21. P.9)
between 50 and
5 is that of a mere ZERO, therefore my promise is fullfilled by writing
Some Prophet !!
This juggling with
figures and adding/deleting zeroes had been the hallmark of Qadiani Movement.
During his lifetime (before 1908) Mirza Ghulam had claimed that he had
hundreds of thousands of followers but the census conducted by the British
Government in India in 1931 revealed the real figure of Qadiani followers
to be not more than 70 thousand. Similarly the present leader, Mirza Tahir,
has been claiming ever increasing numbers of converts - the figure for
this year being 1.5 million. One can easily now draw conclusions as to
the accuracy of such claims. Like prophet like follower!
CLAIMS OF GOOD
CONDUCT IN THEORY:
God is the one who has
sent his mesenger, this humble self, with good conduct and manners.” (Roohani
Khazain Vol 17 P. 426 by Mirza Qadiani)
"They (Muslims) have
hurled all sorts of obscenities at me but I have not even answered back
anyone with abusive language” (Roohani Khazain Vol. 19 P. 236 by Mirza
CONDUCT IN PRACTICE:
"To curse is not the
habit of SIDDIQ (Truthfuls). Faithful do not curse." (Roohani Khazain
"Molvis are liars and
like dogs eat the dead meat of falsehood." (Roohani Khazain vol.11 p.309)
"Except for the children
of prostitutes, whose hearts have been sealed by God, everyone else has
accepted me and attest to my prophethood." (Roohani Khazain vol.5 p.
Enemies have become
swines of our jungle and their women have (become ) worse than bitches.”
(Roohani Khazain vol. 14 p.53)
For his opponent Maulvi
Mohammed Hussein Batalvi, Mirza writes:
"I am telling you
truthfully, that civilised actors and imitators would have at least some
modesty and the ignominious of generations would also not utter such mean
and boastful arrogance from their tongue.." (Roohani Khazain vol.4 p.10)
"Abdul Haq Ghaznavi
writes repeatedly that in the prophecy of Atham, (christian) priests have
won, what can I say in reply except: O Badzaat (despicable)! Jewish Natured!
The face of priest have been blackened and so is yours ..... O Khabees!
How long are you going to live? ... especially on this Head of Dajjals
and his entire group, ONE MILLION shoes of the Curses of Allah may afflict
them. O Dirty Dajjal ! Prejudice has blinded you." (Zamima Anjam-e-Atham,
Roohani Khazain vol.11 p.329)
"O Barbarian of some
Junlge!.... to hide the truth you have eaten this Iguana of falsehood...
O badzaat (despicable), Khabees (evil)! Enemy of Alah and Rasool! You have
done this Jewish alteration ... but your lie O Worthless has been caught....
the day when all these things (regarding Mohammadi Begum's prophecy) are
fulfilled, then on that day would these stupid remain alive? ... There
won't be any place for them to run and their noses would be cleanly cut
(they would be humiliated) and the black spots of disgrace will turn their
MANHOOS (cursed) faces like those fo pigs and monkeys."
(Zamima Anjam-e-Atham, Roohani Khazain vol.11 p.334-337)
Khazain vol. 8 pp 158-162)
Mirza Ghulam Ahmad sent
some thousand curses on some of the Christians. This is nothing unusual,
he had always been very quick with his cursing like a machine gun. But
this time he really went over board. He enumerated these curses from 1
- 1000 in his book Noor-ul-Haq!
A well known fact
which is also an article of faith of all Muslims is that all Prophets of
Allah had excellent conduct. It is unthinkable that a person at the pinnacle
pf humanity, holding the office of Prophethood, would have even one, let
alone four characteristics of hypocricy. We see in our everyday life that
even to admit an ordinary soldier into the army there is a certain criteria
that has to be met. Would Allah not have have any criteria for admitting
someone into His army of Prophets?
Look at the life
of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani. Does it prove him to be a decent human being,
let alone a prophet? In the light of Hadith of Holy Prophet SAAW, Mirza
Saheb fits the descriotion of a PERFECT HYPOCRITE. It is for this reason
that from the platform of Anti Ahmadiyya Movement, I, Dr. Syed Rashid Ali,
have repeatedly challenged Mirza Tahir Ahmad Qadiani, 4th Khalifa and Head
of Ahmadiyya Movement, to declare on oath that the founder of their Movement
was not Perfect Hypocrite. But Alas! He keeps avoiding meeting this challenge
for reasons best known to himself. I am, however, once again challenging
him for Mubahila.
OF MUBAHILA TO AMEER JAMA'AT AHMADIYYA,
TAHIR AHMAD QADIANI,
KHALIFAH AND GRANDSON OF MIRZA GHULAM AHMAD QADIANI
Dr. Syed Rashid Ali, hereby challenge Mirza Tahir Ahmad Qadiani to a Mubahila.
From 1st December
1998 within a period of three months Mirza Tahir Ahmad Qadiani should announce
the acceptance of this challenge. (Note this challenge was given initially
on 1st September 1998 but so far there has been no response from Mirza
The Qadiani Headquarter,
AlFazl Mosque, on 16-18 Gressenhall Road, London SW18
and Time of Mubahila:
Any date and time
according to the convenience of Mirza Tahir Ahmad.
In the presence
of public (qadiani and others) and 4 witnesses from either side, both parties
will declarae the following on oath:
will declare on oath on Holy Quran that "according to the criteria laid
down by Hadith of Holy Prophet Muhammad SAAW, Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani,
the founder of Ahmadiyya Movement and the claimant of prophethood/messiahship/mahdihood,
is a PERFECT HYPOCRITE, as proven by his writings".
Tahir A Qadiani will declare on oath on Holy Quran that "Dr. Syed Rashid
Ali is a liar in his oath and that his Grandfather/Prophet/Promised Messiah/Mahdi
has NEVER LIED, NEVER EMBEZZLED, NEVER BROKEN A PROMISE and has NEVER USED
ABUSIVE LANGUAGE TOWARDS HIS OPPONENTS.
After taking the
oath, both parties will complete the mubahila by invoking the curse of
Allah by reciting the following verse of Holy Quran:
CURSE OF ALLAH BE UPON LIARS
Mr Mirza Tahir Ahmad
I hope that once
again you will not try to run away from this challenge. Your reluctance
to accept this challenge of Mubahila and not facing the challenge within
the stipulated period would mean that you are aware of the true character
of your Grandfather and are delibrately hiding these facts from your simple-minded
followers and others. Perhaps you can decieve people in this world, but
remember you have to face Allah one day. How will you decieve Him? I have
come out to protect the honour of My Beloved Prophet Muhammad SAAW. If
you really believe in the truthfulness of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad, then your
faith in him demands that you come face to face with me for this challenge
of Mubahila. I dare you Mirza Tahir!
May Allah protect
ignorant unsuspecting Muslims as well as simple-minded qadiani/ahmadis
from the pious fraud of Ahmadiyya Movement in the name of Islam. Ameen.
Wa maa 'alainaa ill-alBalaagh.
Dr. Syed Rashid Ali
Anti Ahmadiyya Movement
P O Box 11560
United Arab Emirates