Anti Ahmadiyya Movement in Islam
23rd December 1998
 

CORRESPONDENCE WITH AHMADIYYA HEADQUARTER

(Translation by Dr. Syed Rashid Ali)
23/12/1988
 
PRESS& PUBLICATION DESK,
AHMADIYYA MUSLIM ASSOCIATION
16-18, GRESSENHALL ROAD
LONDON SW18 5QL
 

Mr. Abdul Hafeez Shah,

Received your one long letter addressed to Hazrat Mirza Tahir Ahmad, Imam Jama’at Ahmadiyya, in which you have renewed old objections and and have levelled serious charges against Jama’at Ahmadiyya . After getting fed up of these very charges, Imam Jama’at Ahmadiyya issued a challenge of mubahilla and filed his case in the court of God. In first letter we had made it clear that for mubahilla it is not necessary that both parties should gather at one place. Imam Jama’at Ahmadiyya has used that way of mubahilla which Holy Quran has mentioned in the verse of mubahilla. But in this matter you have shown such extreme non-seriousness that you have suggested, "both of us enter the fire he who is burnt will be a lair beyond doubt and who survives will be truely truthful".

Mubahilla is actually the name given to prayer made to God with humility, so that He will reveal the difference between the lair and truthful party and since God is present everywhere in this universe so He is capable of making us the culprit in London of your curse and affecting you from our curse wherever you are.

From your letter it is evident that opinion you have formed of Jama’at Ahmadiyya is totally based on reading the opponent’s literature. This is extremely wrong that, you should, after reading those lines from the litrature of opponents of Ahmadiyyat, which have been distorted to clearly misguide general public, form any opinion. Fairness demands that first you should have read the litrature of Jama’at Ahmadiyya and then formed any opinion. If you like, the book of Hazrat Mirza Saheb "Haqeeqat-il-Wahi" be sent to you, reading of which necessary in this respect and if don’t like to read it then at least read Hazarat Sahib’s poetry "Dur-e-Sameen" the copy of which will be sent to you shortly. Then, after prayers, tell with fear of God that are these the same sayings which our opponenets present out of context. Wise man walks on this path with full research, honesty and fear of God. After reading all this if you still insists on your stand and are willing to become the second party in this mubahilla then wait fot the manifestation of the Anger of God that what it reveals. We are sure that God, who has so far shown many positive signs, in future also, will show bright signs of the truthfulness of Ahmadiyyat and your wrongfulness, within one year, if God willing.
 

Rasheed Ahmad Choudhry,
Press Secretary
Jama’at Ahmadiyya
23/12/88
 


 

Syed Abdul Hafeez Shah
BAIT-UL-MUKARRAM TRUST (REGD)
P.O.Box Gujjo
Distt Thatta SIND
PAKISTAN.

To,
Mr. Raseed Ahmad Choudhry,
Press Secretary,
LONDON SW18

With reference to you letter dated 23.12.1988, in reply to your statement, that we have reaffirmed old objections and levelled serious charges against you and after getting fed up you have adopted the method of mubahilla, we would like to say that accusations whether old or new, are still accusations. They are either made to reveal the truth or else, to bother someone unneccessarily, then it is a different thing. In either case the accused is given full opportunity to defend himself in worldly & religious courts.

The method you have adopted for mubahilla is wrong because by not fixing the time, date and place and adopting the method of cursing while sitting at home, you have blatantly disregarded the Quranic Law. Holy Prophet (PBUH) after the revelation of the verse of Mubahilla called the Christian priests of Najran and told them "come let us do Mubahilla so that differentiation can be done as to who is the truthful and who is the lair" Furthermore Holy Prophet (PBUH) at the same time appointed the date and place. Therfore it is not right for you to say that it is not compulsory to have an appointed place and time for mubahilla.

Kindly answer following questions:

1) In Kishtee-e-Nooh p. 88 it is written:

To cut short only few lines are copied here. Rest of the book read yourself and for my satisfaction explain to me either this is true what is mentioned above or else Kishtee-e-Nooh has also been published by one of your opponents to defame your creed and this book is not from you. I don’t want to go into its details nor do I want to prolong this topic.

I also want to verfiy following statements of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani whther they are true or not:

  1. "A MUSLIM WHO DOESS’NT CONSIDER ME A PROPHET IS KAFIR . DO NOT OFFER HIS JANAZA (FUNERAL PRAYER) NOR MARRY WITH HIM ."
  2. Do you consider Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani the Promised Maseeh and Mahdi, whose claims he has made?
  3. Is Ahmadiyya creed against Jehad or not?
  4. In the previous letter, illnesses ( of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad ) have been pointed out. Are they entirely wrong and based on accusations only?
  5. Did Mirza Ghulam Ahmad not used to take opium and tonic wine?
  6. Do you recite (or mean while reciting) Ahmad instead of Muhammad (PBUH) in the Kalima and
  7. Have alterations been made in Holy Quran or not?
A part from all these things, very respectfully, extending the circle of our correspondence, now we will analyse with honesty that for nearly 75 years why there is this rift and what method should be adopted to solve it? Bigotry and unneccssary accusations should stop. I will very eagerly wait for the books sent by you. Insha’allah you will find me honest in my criticism.
 
Respected Mr. Mirza Tahir Ahmad
By keeping quiet this world, you think you have saved your skin . But on the Day of Judgement, finally right and wrong will be decided. There you will not be able to convert a false claimant into a True prophet.

Signed: Syed Abdul Hafeez Shah
Gujjo District Thatta

cc:
Mr. Yousuf Shohail Sharq.
Jama'at Ahmadiyya Office
Rabwa, Pakistan.


 

PRESS & PUBLICATION DESK,
AHMADIYYA MUSLIM ASSOCIATION
LONDON SW18 5QL.
 

Mr. Syed Abdul Hafeez Shah Sahib

As promised We are sending Hazrat Mirza Sahib ‘s book of poetry Dure-eSameen."

Rasheed Ahmad Chaaudhry,
29.1.1989.

BAIT-UL- MUKARRAM TRUST (REGD)
P.O.Box Gujjo Dist. Thatta Sindh Pakistan

To,
Mr. Rasheed Ahmad Chaudhry,
Press Secretary,
Jama’at Ahmadiyya
London. SW18
February 1989.

Respected Mr. Press Secretary,

Received your book ‘Dur-e-Sameen" Thank you.

I was actually waiting for the reply of my letter and I still am. Probably you have understood my point of view from my writings. I am enclosing the copy of my pervious letter that might not have reached you for which I am writing this letter. Hopefully, you will try broadmindedly to prevent someone, who is honestly trying to analyse your beliefs in historical perspective, from getting lost in the maze of doubts and confusion.

I hope you will not refuse this small request will benefit you only.
Please do answer the questions which I have asked after discussing them with Mirza Tahir Ahmad. Your silence may not be due to your running away (I hope), which I don't want. I hope you will keep this in mind that this correspondence with you is only and only for the sake of ALLAH.

SYED ABDUL HAFEEZ SHAH
GUJJO, SIND PAKISTAN.

BAIT-UL- MUKARRAM TRUST (REGD)
P.O.Box Gujjo Dist. Thatta Sindh Pakistan
FEBRUARY 1989

ANNECDOTES and COMPLAINTS
I will start my composition with a pleasant joke. As the story goes, one person used sell oil for baldness, after gathering people around him. Praising it, he used to make his audience feel that it is an effective cure for all types of badness. When people get impressed by his speech, he used to sell bottles of oil. Once he was selling oil to an audience, suddenly his wife came running full of anger and immediately took the cap off her husband’s head. Everybody saw that he himself was bald :)))

False prophet’s forceful writings and and speeches impressed people and during it many times people tried to pull his his headgear. Debates took place, many Mubahilas took place and that cap after transferring from one head to another, is now on Mirza Tahir Ahmad’s head. He should treat his own faithlessness before his cap is taken off.

STORY OF FOLLOWER OF A SPIRITUAL GUIDE

The student was going on the right path, spritual exercises and prayers were in full swing when suddenly he stopped visiting his teacher. After sometime the teacher sent another student to find out about his condition. He went and asked the reason for absence. That student said that now he doesn’t require a teacher or a guide since Gabriel is coming every night with Burraq (Flying Horse) and take him for a ride to seven heavens; he is the second man after Prophet Mohammad (PBUH) who is going daily to heavens with body and soul. The student left quietly and informed the teacher. The teacher said "Give him my messege: when next time you are touring the heavens, once according to my instruction recite LA HAWLAA WA LAA QUWATAA ILLA BILLAH. Next night as usual he rode the horse and while touring the heavens he rememberd teacher’s instrutions and recited the verse. Immediatly everything became dark and he discovered that he is on a hill of rubbish riding a donkey. In the morning he went to the teacher, repented and started his usual chores all over again. Something similar happened with our Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani.

STORY OF HAZRAT SHAIKH ABDUL QADIR JEELANI (RA)

Once He was busy in prayers one night when he saw light across the sky and a voice said "O Abdul Qadir! I am very happy with you. Until now everything that was forbidden even for Prophets, you are allowed to use them". Immediatly Shaikh thought that he is a very small person as compared to a Prophet. This must be the devil or Satan. He recited LA HAWLAA WA LAA QUWATAA ILLA BILLAH. The light diappeared and again a voice said: "Abdul Qadir your knowledge saved you." Again Shaikh recited LA HAWLAA WA LAA QUWATAA ILLA BILLAH and said: I was saved by Allah’s Grace."

REASON FOR MIRZA'S CLAIM OF PROPHETHOOD

According to my research at one time, Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani was engrossed in spritiual exercises. He fasted for continous six months, prayed Tahajjud and got engaged in Zikr and Fikr. Unfortunately he could not get spiritual guide who could steer him through this period. Spiritual elation and happenings (dreams etc.) which are the necessary result of such excercises, started to take place for Mirza also, for example true dreams, prior information of tuture happenings and similar things which are quite unusual and supernatural. There is a famous saying that an ignorant sufi is worst than Satan. By ignorance I don’t mean bookish knowledge but the insight and understanding. Who doesn’t know that Satan, despite being the teacher of Angles, made the claim of "Iam better that him (Adam)’ in fornt of his Creator. As a result he was thrown out of His (Allah) favours and for this mistake there is neither any forgivenss nor redemption, because sins are of two types:

Sins comitted through weakness of flesh can be repented upon and forgiven. But sins through pride of flesh will not be forgiven. Thus when Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani was passing through this phase of supernatural happenings, Satan transpired him to lay the claim of prophethood and for this neither is there any redemption nor forgiveness. During this period he wrote some 60 - 80 books. Simple Muslims including ladies, kept coming to him with their problems hoping to get some benifit. This is a very common happening in our Indo-pak culture which can be observed during all times in every city, people asking for 'Ta'aweez', emulets etc. Even a mad man gathers a crowd around him. Mirza was after all somewhat educated, so gathering of people around him was nothing new. Before laying the false claim for prophethood, he proclamimed himself "Mujaddid". Then certain educated people joined him for their own reasons and gave him suggestions. Mujaddid climbed up to proclaim the station of Promised Messiah and Mehdi. Now he gave the verdict (Fatwa) that anyone who believes in him is a muslim and who doesn’t is Kaafir.

Fact is that neither Mirza had the qualification to be called an A‘lim (religious scholar) nor he had completed the course of Mufti (an authority who can issue Fatwa) to issue Fatwa, and likewise did not give his hand into the hands of any Spiritual Guide or Shaikh. Plain truth is that Mirza neither completed his education nor could he bear the burden of Prophet, as a result he developed following illness:

PREDICATIONS AND THEIR TRUE NATURE WITH RESULTS HIS EVERY PREDICATION PROVED WORNG
  1. Predication of his marriage with Mohammadi Begum proved wrong.
  2. Prediction of Marriage with a widow.
  3. He said for Deputy Abdullah Atham that he will die on 6th September but it did not happen.
  4. Molvi Sanaullah Amratsari, he predicated, will die in his lifetime whereas he (Moulvi Sahab) died in 1974 Mirza died in 1908.
HOW IGNORANT AND SIMPLE MUSLIMS BECOME QADIANI?

Few points to ponder:

1. To trap simple muslims, he (Mirza) said;

2. Apart from this trap Qadianis, wearing a clock of holiness, uses the second weapon of fear through psychological pressures to impress people with feeble nerves. For example "wait for the subduing sign", "bad end", "dying from cholera"  ---------all these are their famous phrases.

3. Mirza Saheb, because of uttering such curses, had submitted the following affidavit of repentance in the Court of Deputy Commissioner, Gurdwaspur.

  1. I will prevent myself from publishing any such predictions which are insulting to anybody or implicates anyone in God’s punishment.
  2. I will refrain from publishing anything saying it to be inspiration.
  3. I will not call anyone name liked Dajjal, Kafir (Disbeliever), Lair Batalvi.
  4. And I will not request for Mubahilla. And as far as in my power, all people upon whom I have some influnce, I will induce them to follow the way upon which I have promised to follow."

    5. Signed: Mirza Ghulam Ahmad (through his hands)
    Witness: Khawja Kamaluddin B.A.Ll.B.
    Signed: District Magistrate Gurdaspur, (J.M. Dowie )
    Date 24th February 1899.

    "Thus if I have submitted in front of Mr Dowie that i will not call him (Molvi Mohammed Hussein Batalvi) Kafir, then truly this is my religion that I do not consider any Muslim a Kafir."

    (Tiryaq-ul-Quloob, Roohani Khazain vol.15 p.433)

What kind of a Prophet or Messiah or Mahdi would relinquish his 'DIVINELY_ORDAINED TASK' for the fear of reprisals from authorities? Moreover would any Prophet/Messiah/Mahdi flout his promise or pledge?

Despite this affidavit, Mirza Ghulam Ahmad and his followers persued the same old course. Affidavit of repentance became the affidavit of lies and till this day they (Qadianis) are using one of these means to trap simple muslims.

Their another notorious weapon is Mubahilla. This too is based on twisting the words cunningly. For example " that person accepted our Challenge of mubahilla and met bad fate ---either he died or met an accident" Such stories are distorted and given wide publicised so that people get scared and become impressed with them. Any non-qadiani dying anywhere and by any means, they take the cerdit (that he died of their curse) If a Qadiani dies, who should take the cerdit? Do some justice and tell us.

How amazing this statement is that Mr. Bhutto Marhoom was hanged because he passed the law declaring Qadianis non-Muslims and Zia-ul-Haque Marhoom died in accident because he disgraced and defamed qadianis. Whereas every Muslim believe that life and death, honour and disgrace is in the hands of God. He has His own Ways. Whenever He wants, He recalls someone and honour to whosoever and whenever He wants.

These Qadianis have helped themselves to being Maseeh and Mahdi, and it seems that they have established relationship with Hazrat Izrael AS (the angel of death). If we study the history of Qadiani (Ahmadiyya) Movement, startling facts are discovered which will make the humanity tremble. For example incidents of killing their opponents, and causing disgrace and dishonour are on record. Also to trap simple people incentives, intimidation, psychological and some social, political and financial pressures are the various means which are adopted by them.

On the other hands if some qadiani wants to become a muslim, then it is very difficult for him to come out of their net. Albeit, there is one way to break their enclosure and enter the folds of Islam whcih is pointed out in this Hadith-e-Nabawi ((PBUH) that unless a Muslim sacrifices his life, honour and his worldly posession for the love of Prophet Mohammad (PBUH) he will not become a true muslim.
 

CONCLUSION & REQUST

"O Allah! You are Wise and Knowledgable. Whatever I am writing here is not my wordly problem nor as a human being I have anything against Qadianis. But since this group (of qadianis) claim to be Muslim, therefore I am trying to fulfil my religious duty and to get the honour of pleasing You and Your Prophet (PBUH). O Allah! please help me and guide Qadianis so that they can repent and join the forces of Islam and add to our strenght and the end of all them is good. Ameen."

Such simple and clear facts do not require any proof or agrument that God will never put the crown of prophethood on a hypochondriac person suffering from scores of illnesses. Whereupon we have seen that this false claimant of prophethood got caught in his own snare and what curses he used to sent upon others, ultimately became own victim and an example for all to see. Suffering from diarrhoea and vomiting (Cholera!!), passed away from this abode of frailty to the abode of permanancy where everyone has to go.

Even now if my talk has not impressed your heart then you say Ameen upon my following prayes:

You only have to say Ameen. Finally, this pryayer is a present for all of you, hoping that Allah will honour me by granting it. Syed Abdul Hafeez Shah
Gujjo Dist Thatta, Pakistan


 

PRESS& PUBLICATION DESK,
AHMADIYYA MUSLIM ASSOCIATION
16-18, GRESSENHALL ROAD,
LONDON SW18 5QL.

Mr. Syed Abdul Hafeez Shah,

Received your both letters with booklet in which most heart-breaking things are said for Hazrat Founder of Ahmadiyya Movement. Imam Jamaat Ahmadiyya, Hazrat Mirza Tahir Ahmad, gave the challenge of Mubahilla on June 15th, 1988 to all leaders of disbelievers, because we want judgement from the court of Allah, where neither flattery nor lies work, about false and baseless objections raised by the opponents of Ahmadiyyat during the hundred years.

But Alas! Even after the passage of one year most opposition leaders could not get resolved to accept the challenge of Mubahilla unconditionally. You have announced four conditions in the booklet including the ridiculous suggestion of jumping into the fire. If you had the slightest fear of Allah in your heart you should have accepted the Mubhilla as it is or else apologised from it like the Christians of Najran.

Imam Jamaat Ahmadiyya has given the chellenge of Mubahilla exactly according to the teaching of Quran. In all fairness it should have been taken seriously but you gave it a turn towards debate demanding magic tricks. If that is the standard of Mubahilla for you then, then very gladly you collect your followers and jump into the fire and thus provide evidence for the truthfulness of your claim. We have no objection at all.

By the Mubahilla we mean to ask through prayers, for Allah’s Judgement. Imam Jamaat Ahmadiyya has announced the challenge on 15th June 1988, as the first party representing all ahmadi males and females. Now whoever likes to accept the Mubahilla by signing as the second party and say " Curse of Allah be up on the lairs" and then wait to see with in one year the Allah’s verdict.

Concerning those questions which you have asked many times, they have been answered in the literature of Jamaat Ahmadiyya, Also in the pamphlet of Mubhilla many of these have been kept as the differentiating signs between right and wrong thereby making it clear that objections raised against the faith of Jamaat Ahmadiyya from any quarters are all worng and lies.

Shah Sahib! By the Grace of God we have complete faith in 'La ilaha illaAllah Muhamadur Rasoolullah'. This is our spirit and this our life. All nations of the world, let alone Pakistan, cannot erase the Kalima Tayyebah from the heart of any ahmadi. They can cut the body of an ahmadi into pieces but by God they can’t subdue the voice of 'La ilaha illaAllah Muhamadur Rasoolullah' coming from every piece of flesh. Listen very carefully that Mohammad AlArabi (peace be upon Him) is our Lord, for whom our body, soul and money ---- everything is sacrificed and to introduce us to the Exalted position of this Rasool-e-Arabi (ArabicMessenger) is his humble servent ------ Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad, the Promised Maseeh and Mahdi, through whose efforts we were enabled to call ourselves muslims in true sense.

We are following all the tenets of Islam therfore how can we deny Jehad. Just see with your open eyes and you will realize that it is only Jamaat Ahmadiyya who is busy in spreading Islam wordwide, and no day is dawned when thousands of good souls are not embracing the faith by reciting the Kalima of Mohammad, The Messenger of Allah (PBUH). This is Jihad Shah Sahib and not the one in which you and the likes of you are busy, who have understood only this meaning of Jihad - to kill ahmadis, burn their houses and to snatch their valuables and to wipe off Kalima from the walls of their mosques.

Whether it is the war in Kashmir, or the Jihad of spreading Quran worldwide or the correction of inner self or the Jihad of spreading the messege of Islam everywhere, Jamaat Ahmadiyya is by the Grace of God busy in these Jihads. Your query that there is a conflict between muslim for last 75 years, what should be the way to solve it. It’s Quranic solution was Mubahilla from which Molvis have run away. Shah Sahib hundered years ago a lonely voice arose from Qadian which have now converted into ten millions and day by day the caravan of Ahmadiyyat is moving ahead. If at times certain fearful and bad voices are heard then such voices are usually raised to accelerate the speed of caravan. Only foolish pay any heed to them.

On the one hand you accepted the Mubahilla challenge and the other hand you tried to bluff the world by pretending as if you have given the challenge and Imam Jamaat Ahmadiyya has to accept it. If that is so, then we pray to God that considering your act as an acceptance of mubahilla, He (God) should reveal His subduing sign so that those in search of truth can benefit from it.

Signed: Rahseed Ahmad Chaudhary
Press Secretary
Jamaat Ahmadiyya London.
 


 
BAIT-UL- MUKARRAM TRUST (REGD)
P.O.Box Gujjo Dist. Thatta Sindh Pakistan
 

Mr. Mirza Tahir Ahmad
Imam, Jamaat Ahmadiyya International

Respected (as a Human being) Mirza Tahir Ahmad ,

                                        Ref: your letter Dated 25/6/1989.

Founder of Jamaat Ahmadiyya says:

All Ahnafs (Following the Fiqah of Imam Abu Hanifa) agrees with above mentioned declaration except Jihad or Holy war which is not mentioned here. Anybody who has the following beliefs is not a Muslim but a disbeliever (KAFIR) and on the basis of these beliefs, religious scholars of Ahle Sunnah wal Jamaat have labeled Qadianis as KAFIR:-
  Above mentioned statements of Ghulam A. Qadiani are presented to you. If as you say, your opponents are misqouting Mirza Ghulam Qadiani to defame you all, then whichever statement is wrong amongst these, kindly correct it and send it to me at your earliest.

Before I start replying to your letter, I feel that I must reiterate my point of view and tell you that my correspondence is solely for the sake of Allah and start my letter with this prayer:

Dear Sir your plea is that you have adopted this method of Mubahilla in accordance with established system, because people give wrong proofs from your books and according to their wishes present distored text to mislead people. In answer to this statement, I would like to point out that in your challenge of Mubahilla, by not specifying the time and place you have blatantly disobeyed Quranic orders. Just as in the verse of Mubahilla No, 61, Surah,3 ) Prophet of Allah (PBUH) has specified the time and place for Mubhilla with Chiristians of Najran and this the only way according to Quran and Sunnah. Your statement is illogical that you will sit in your house and curse and the opponnents will do it in their homes and since God is present everywhere and whereever the opponents are, they will be afflicted by the curse.

Until now all information that I have recieved points towards one thing only and that is that you have made it a practice of runing away from every front. In answer to your challenge of Mubahilla, I had written four conditions for accepting your challenge. One of these i.e. entering the fire, you said is a ridiculous idea. You should have really commented on the other three conditions also or labeled them ridiculous as well. At least that would have satisfied me that you have given answers according to your capabilities. Since this is not done, I am mentioning once again rest of the three conditions:-

  1. We will sit in two seprate rooms in any city; after three days of meditation and prayers , we come out of our rooms and people will see on our faces who is right and who is wrong.
  2. Open the grave of your grandfather-Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani and whole will see wether he was a true prophet or a lair.
  3. Does forty years of life of Mirza Qadiani resemble with any prophet? I wanted that you should have written yourself the life history of Ghulam Qadiani so that at least the answer of my challenge had been completed.
I request you most respectfully that as you promised, I sincerely want to study those books which you like that your opponents are using against you. It is a very sensitive issue. My intention is neither to hurt your feelings nor do I have any grandiose ideas. Rather as a student, I very honestly want to clarify all doubts with great care through your own pen so that I can also convince your opponents that these people (Qadianis) are on the right path and we are on the wrong one. Since these two things are not correct according to my present state of knowledge, they need some detailed explanation.

Your statement is that I have hurt your feelings in the book "2 in 1" I will quot once again the book "Kishtee-e-Nooh" pp 88-89, that Mirza was first Maryam then through insufflation became pregnant and finally delivered through his own abdomen as Eisa (Jesus). Whatever the artist got from this saying, we printed it as the Title Cover. If any other artist after reading these lines, can draw some other graphic to express them and at the same time it does not offend you, then please send it to us. I promise you that all remaining copies of "2in1" will be burnt and another book with your title picture on it and an apology by me will be printed.

Kindly answer the following questions at your earliest. I would be mot grateful if you do so. It is quite possible that I may be able to understand all complicated issues which at present I am unable to follow.

  1. What is the definition of a true prophet?
  2. What is the identity of a false prophet?
  3. According to Prophet Mohammad’s (PBUH) Hadith there will be thirty false claimants in his Ummah. Please state how many have passed and how many are remaining?
  4. You said from one Qadiani in hundred years there are ten million qadianis. For your information Shaitan (Devil) was also one in the begining and there millions and millions of his students and followers. He can also claim that he alone have made millions of devils, so he is on the right path! Allah Almighty has kept good and bad things in this world. For people following the right path there are certain rules and regulations and for people on the wrong path, like wise there are certain conditions, whose explanations and details have been mentioned in Holy Quran by Allah and in his lifetime Prophet (PBUH)  made clear as to what is right and what is wrong and on this only depends rewards and punishment. It is obvious that if in contrast to True prophet there is no false prophet how will one recognize the True Prophet, just as if night and days are not there you would not recognize the light.
  5. You have said that Ahmadis (qadianis) have been killed and their houses looted but then they are standing by their truth and holding on to their faith on the Promised Maseeh. They are bearing all hardships. Let me tell you that history of Qadian is a witness that in 1857 AD to massacre Muslims your great grandfather (Mirza's father) supplied fifty horses and fighters with arms to the British Government to prove his faithfulness and the muslim blood was shed wrongly (Tohfa-e-Qaiser, p, 16, Roohani Khazain vol.12 p.270 by Mirza Ghulam A Qadiani) What I am trying to prove by these examples is that the very foundation of your religion is kept on violence and oppression. The whole world is ignorant and your schemes are continuing to destory the Muslims. Oppressing others and calling yourself oppressed! Allah is going to make Justice. By the way let me tell you this thing that the night when your challenge of Mubahilla was discretely dropped in houses in Orangi Township, Karachi, one Muslim collected some of the copies and wanted to destroy them, when some qadianis caught hold of him, beaten up and they snatched those copies away. This incidence of the Orangi Township is present on the record that the curfew was imposed there and as always, your people were given protection. If in your dictionary the injured is considerd as oppressor and wrong doer as oppressed then it just indicates your Just nature! If you want I can provide you details with proofs as to how ahmadis are still persisting in their voilent and oppressing activities against Muslims. I am not going into the details for fear of lenghty discussion.
  6. In your excittement you have claimed that if we cut you into pieces, we will hear voices of Kalima "There is no god but Allah" from every piece. I wish such a statement would come from Al-Madina Al-Munawwarah instead of London and you had stayed in Al-Madina at all cost and faced consequences of all restrictions imposed on you. Your statement reminded me of Hazrat Bilal Habshi (may Allah be pleased with him). In love of Prophet (PBUH) he received lashes causing the skin of his back to break, and he was made to lie on hot sand. There is a world of difference between his call of "La Ilaha illa Allah" and your saying. Your Qibla is London and the faithfulness to Brithish is now more than hundred years old, where you have complete protection of life and property. Your present life is passing in peace and prosperity and Allah only knows what will happen in life hereafter.
  7. Is the accusation of Alteration in Holy Quran on Mirza Ghulam A. Qadiani, wrong or correct?
I will be very eagerly waiting for the reply. I hope you will answer all questions at your first opportunity.

I think I have completed from my side whatever I can write. I don’t have to add anything more. Albeit, I would very much like to read from your own pen the decision of right or wrong, and with honesty form a correct opinion about you to inform all Muslims that you people are the wronged ones, accused of false things and defamed . OR ELSE you people are the wrong ones, have lost sight of the right path and are trapping innocent and ignorant people by tempatation, greed and other such means and make them fuel for Hell.

May Allah give you good sense and faith. After this letter I will wait for your reply for one month. If I don’t get any answer, I will hand over all this correspondence to the newsmedia all over the world.

Signed: Syed Abdul Hafeez Shah
Gujjo, District Thatta, Pakistan


 

PESS& PUBICATION DESK,
AHMADIYYA MUSLIM ASSOCIATION
16-18, GRESSENHALL ROAD,
LONDON SW18 5QL

Mr. Syed Abdul Hafeez Shah Sahib ,

Recieved your letter, in which once again you tried to distort the facts and in certain cases leaving aside the context, tried to pin on us such beliefs which are never Jamaat-e-Ahmadiyya’s and neither in the Torah of Hazrat Maseeh Mawood P.B.U.H. whose references you have given, those are meant which you have taken. Your way of presenting the shortened references is the same as some stupid person says that since in Quran-e-Karim it is said La Taqrabu as-salaat (Do not near prayers) therfore I don’t pray. As far as the beliefs of Jamaat-e-Ahmadiyya is concerned you yourself in the begining of your letter have mentioned a reference from the book of Hazrat Founder of Ahmadiyya Movement " Ayyam-e-Sulh" and have confirmed that all Ahnafs are in agreement on these beliefs. Once again I am bringing that reference to your notice to request that please read it again and calmly without any prejudice think that can such people whose beliefs are these, be considered outside the fold of muslim Ummah? Founder of Ahmadiyya Movement says:

And the beliefs of Jamaat-e-Ahmadiyya regarding Hazrat Mohammad PBUH is evident in following lines of the founder of Ahmadiyya Movement. God is witness that these are the beliefs of Jamaat Ahmaidyya, which are mentioned in the above quotations and Hazrat founder of Ahmadiyya Movement has this position. Now after these writings, clear as day light, your objections have no value. Hence amongst 24 references, all those references which, according to you, are insultive from any angle towards prophet PBUH, other prophets, Quran-e-Karim and Islam, are clear cut slander and lie upon Jamaat Ahmadiyya. No man with insight, no just man can draw the same conclusion from these writings which you have drawn. Those writings in which founder of ahmadiyya Movement has proved the death of Hazrat Eisa, that has been proved according to Quran and Hadith and has shown that Quran and Hadith bear witness to his death. Now after this clear explanation, if you really still take those meanings from such writings, which you have mentioned then we can’t say anything except "Curse of Allah be upon the Lairs."

You have kept four conditions for Mubahilla, all of which are absurd and ridiculous. It seems that you are completely ignorant of the teachings of Holy Quran, otherwise you would have never offered such meaningless conditions. For example, about the condition of jumping into the fire, Qruan reveals in Surah Burooj that the enemies of prophets and people of Numord like qualities try to burn good men of God in the fire. Your indentity has revealed by your absurd condition that Holy Quran considers you in what type of people. Similarly other conditions also, i.e. locking in two rooms and opening the grave, also shows that you are completely ignorant in religious matters and you do not know anything about the way of prophets. Tell me from which God’s book or Hadith you have taken such course of action.

As far as the life of the founder of  Ahmadiyya movement before the claim is concerned, it is clean and pious and like prophets, no objections can be raised on his pious life. In the end of your letter you have raised certain questions, whose answers are given briefly.

We pray this that May God show you the right path and give you the understanding of real truth . Ameen .

Rasheed Ahmad Chaudhry
Jamaat Ahmadiyya
London. Dated 5th Jan 1989.


 
BAIT-UL- MUKARRAM TRUST (REGD)
P.O.Box Gujjo Dist. Thatta Sindh Pakistan
15th Jan, 1990

Mr. Rasheed Ahmad Chowdhry

I am in honour of the reciept of your letter dated 5.1.90. This is the second time you have reiterated your accusation that we have distorted the facts and in certain cases taking out of context, we have tried to label such beliefs on you which are not those of Jamaat Ahmadiyya. Once again following quotations are mentioned:
 

In these 23 quotations whatever mistakes are there point them out because this is your religious duty; or else you write that the books from which these quotations have been taken are not written by Mirza Ghulam Ahmad ; rather they are written by enemies. Surprisingly on the one hand founder of Ahmadiyya movement boldly announces his beliefs in detail similar to those of ours (except Jihad) and on the other hand are these twenty three qoutations; one of them has to be wrong. Hopefully you will seriously guide me in this matter. You are mistaken that I have unneccessarily drawn any conclusion from these twenty four points.

Once again your reply is incomplete because you have briefly commented on the death of Hazrat Essa (PBUH) and ignored the rest of the 22 points.

I pray to Allah: 
O Allah! those who are trying to defame the qadiani beliefs & which are right only because of prejudice, then thousand times curse be upon them, and the disgrace of this world and thereafter become their fate. Otherwise if this is not the case then O Allah all Qadianis should meet the same fate as that of the founder of Ahmadiyya Movement. Ameen.

Now regarding the four conditions of Mubahilla, I am very glad that you have stated them to be ridiculous and non Islamic. But your’s is a much more ridiculous one that you send the curse sitting in your house and we curse sitting in our houses. In the verse of Mubahilla time and place is categorically fixed and you have ignored it very conveniently. If I am completely ignorant in your matters then what is the meaning of all this correspondence and waste of time. The suggestion of opening the grave was made because bodies of Prophets and Martyrs are preserved in their graves. If your founder is as you say, a Prophet, then he will be safe in his grave and people will have the honour of seeing him and will become qadiani and this will be a big success. As for the ground for opening the graves, they have been opened in the past albeit for differnt reasons. For example in 1932 ruler of Iraq Malik Faisal I was told in dream by the great Sahabi Hazrat Huzaifa Yemani to shift him and Hazrath Jaber Bin Abdulla from their present graves to a place away from river Dajla (Tigris) because of water seeping in his and Hazrat Jaber’s grave. Therfore Fatwa (Religious Injunction) was taken and their grave were opened and their bodies were shifted from there. If you had agreed on this then I would have surely taken permission from all the religious scholars of India and Pakistan and succeed in solving this very big problem in which your own success was also hidden and still is.

You are wrong in saying that no objection can be raised on the clean life of the founder of your movement. You need proof for this claim. Whereas regarding the birth, first he became Maryam then through insufflation became pregnant and then delivered through his own utreus as Eisa (see Kishtee-e-Nooh, pp.87,88,89,) Surprisingly, he does believe in the "Nafakh" of Hazrat Maryam and then accepts Eisa as the son of Yousuf Najjar (Joseph the Carpenter) and through the same "Nafakh" he makes himself pregnant and is born through himself as Eisa. In other words the very birth of the so-called Maseeh Mawood is based on a lie.

Now, regarding the inspirations of the founder of the Ahmadiyya movement, in Braheen-e-Ahmadiyya, two inspirations in English are mentioned here:

Arabic Ispirations:- God knows what, in your opinion, is the picture of a pious life. I have after very honestly studying the life of founder of Ahmadiyya Movement from both angles i.e. worldly and hereafter, drawn the conclusions from his own writings. He says in his own writings that he who is not honoured with the conversation with God and he is telling a lie then his end is exemplary. Regarding his admonitory end whatever is wellknown, you are also aware of it. It is disrespectful to comment on it.

His predictions proved to be compeletely wrong and false, this also I concluded from his own book, for which I am answerable to Allah. Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani says:-

HIS EVERY PREDICATION PROVED WORNG
  1. Predication of his marriage with Mohammadi Begum proved wrong.
  2. Prediction of Marriage with a widow.
  3. He said for Deputy Abdullah Atham that he will die on 6th September but it did not happen.

    4. Molvi Sanaullah Amratsari, he predicated, will die in his lifetime whereas he (Moulvi Sahab) died in 1974 Mirza died in 1908.
So that is the reply for your challenge regarding his pious life. The answers you have given to my questions, I wish you had corrected your direction in the light of those very answers. But Alas! This is not so. You advised that I should read the history of Ahmadiyya movement. Reading has always been purpose of life; however here it is not necessary because you have provided the material for me enough to identify any false prophet. It is my faith that all Prophets are innocent thus as for your founder, there is no comparision between a speck of dirt and those pious souls.

Now as for Jihad (Holy War) so you admit that Mirza’s father did give fifty hourses to the British Government to get its exoneration or to get exoneration from God, any way they were given. In this regard you have given the references of Mr.Mohammad Husain Batlavi and Sir Syed Ahmad Khan. These two person have always been controversial in this matter. It carries no weight apart from the fact that to find an excuse for committing a sin is worse than the sin itself. Since this need a lot of explanation, I want a debate organized in London on the topic of Jihad. If you agree then I can come with some friends to any place you like so that this problem can be solved in this century itself. I can bring those of your books also through which the truth of your contradictory statements can be exposed. To prove yourself Muslim, your job will be to burn those books in public, which have been attributed to your founder and you say that these books do not belong to you nor are they written by the founder of your movement, and you don’t believe in them and this is injustice with you.

Just at the same time, as all this is going on and books are burning, I will be the first man to embrace Mirza Tahir Ahmad, raise the slogan of Allah-o-Akbar (Allah is Great) and announce that all misunderstandings have been resolved and qadianis are really muslims and whatever has been happening to this day was injustice to them. May Allah forgive our sins of injustice with our brethren.

You consider the incidence of Orangi Town as baseless. Let me put it to you that Allah has not given any human being right to burn houses, commit murders and rob people. This is flagrant cruelty whether done by a Muslim or a qadiani. I serve both of them without any prejudice.

Are you justified in claiming to be equal to Bilal Habshi’s enthusastic and passionate will to sacrifice everything in the cause of Islam? Truth of the matter is that on one hand is the claim of love of Prophet (PBUH) and on the other hand only because of fear of restrictions, Khalifa No.4. is enjoying life in London. Why not walk on foot in the love of Prophet PBUH and reach Madina. Inspite of efforts, words cannot encompass the entire truth. Your "Ahad! Ahad!" is only limited upto the founder of your movement. No doubt a tree can be identified from its fruit.

Photocopies of the proof of Alteration in the Holy Quran is presented here. Decide for yourself. I also pray that may Allah give both of us the ability to understand the truth and reality. Ameen.

Note: About "2in1" I asked you for the artistic impression of pages 87, 88,89, of the book " Kishtee-e-Nooh" by the founder of your movement with the promise that if you can provide such a picture which is not offending to you and which truely represents the writing graphically, then send it to me. I promised you that I will burn remaining copies of the "2in1" and reprint them with your picture as title and with an apology. You have not mentioned anything about it. Hopefully you will send it. Kindly reply to this letter within fifteen days receipt of this letter so that I can refain from taking any action. Otherwise I consider it as one of my duties to use information media to show people the true picture of your religion.

Signed: Syed Abdul Hafeez Shah
PO Gujjo, Dist. Thatta
Pakistan.

 
BAIT-UL- MUKARRAM TRUST (REGD)
P.O.Box Gujjo Dist. Thatta Sindh Pakistan
 
MOMENT OF WORRY FOR THE MUSLIM NATION

WILL QADIANIS ANSWER THIS

Can following beliefs be those of any muslim ?:-
 

CAN MIRZA TAHIR AHMAD TELL US
  1. What is the definition of true Prophet?
  2. What is the sign of a false Porphet ?
  3. According to the HADITH of Prophet Mohammad (PBUH) there will be 30 false claimants of Prophethood amongst his Ummah, kindly tell us how many have passed away and how amny are remaining?
  4. In 1857 AD the great grandfather of Mirza Tahir Ahmad ie. Mirza Ghulam Ahmad of Qadian’s father gave 50 armed horsemen to the British Government (who were ruling the India subcontinent at that time) to cursh the muslim resistance for independence, as a proof of his loyalty to the British Raj. Is this true or not?
  5. Is the charge of alteration in Holy Quran on Mirza Ghulam Ahmad true or false?
  6. Will God ever send a Prophet or a reformer who is suffering from
Dear Reader, I beg you in the name of Allah & His Beloved Prophet Mohammad PBUH to ask Mirza Tahir Ahmad, the present Imam of Ahmadiyya Movement, whether the beliefs mentioned above are mentioned by Mirza Ghulam Ahmad in his books or not? If they are, then why Jamaat Ahmadiyya is embarassing the entire Muslim Nation by calling themselves Muslims! If they are not true then I challenge them to prove that I am worng.

Syed Abdul Hafeez Sahah
Gujjo, Tahtta.Pakistan.

Note: Mr Rasheed Chaudhary, Press Secretary of Mirza Tahir Ahmad, stopped responding after these letters and despite repeated reminders, no response was ever shown even to acknowledge our letters. Our repeated challenge of Mubahilas were also neither acknowledged nor accepted. - Dr. Syed Rashid Ali.

Back | Next
Main Page